Thank you for letting us know. We will review this comment.

COOKIES & PRIVACY POLICY

From Russia with Hate: Where is the love?

Reflections on Russia's anti-gay movement

Harriet P Evans

Wed, 22 Aug 2012 17:39:45 GMT | Updated today

When I hear about what is happening in Russia at the moment, I cannot even imagine what it must be like. It's only when I see videos online, when images of the oppression taking place is physically in front of me, that I appreciate how brutal the struggle for equality is. In one such video, a young woman  holds up a rainbow flag. She is shouted at, pushed and physically dragged to the ground, ripping her dress. A man wearing a rainbow sweatband has 'holy' water chucked at him, before being subjected to a flying fist and being dragged away by the police. Sickening stuff.

There are many countries where it is illegal to be gay, and that obviously is not right. But, with homosexuality having been decriminalized in Russia in 1993, you would think this would be a step forward for the equality we are striving to achieve. With such a strong anti-gay sentiment brewing in Russia, however, and the current wave of homophobic legislation and law enforcement, it is hard to say that Russia is doing anything but taking a step back.

Earlier this year this year, a law was passed in St Petersburg banning the promotion of 'homosexual propaganda'. What is propaganda? This ambiguous term could have so many meanings. Is it waving a rainbow flag? Writing a book with gay character? Holding hands with your same-sex partner down the street? If a gay couple has children, everyday they would be breaking the law by 'promoting' a homosexual lifestyle to minors.

The idea behind the law was to protect children so they can uphold 'traditional Russian values'. What values? Hate, prejudice, shame? I have to question the credibility of the powers that be in Russia. How they are running their country? If they want to breed a generation of hate-mongers, what future are they heading for?

With plans to roll out this law nationally across Russia, it seems they are heading down a slippery slope into complete totalitarian control and outright persecution. At the moment, this law does not ban homosexuality, but by banning 'propaganda', a term which is so unclear and so easily twisted, it seems that the Putin government is doing anything it can to push LGBT Russians underground.

You only have to look at the news headlines to sense how anti-gay Russia really is at the moment, and how their homophobic laws are just a by-product of a deeply rooted prejudice amongst the government and (some of) its people.

Last week, three members of the Russian feminist punk group 'Pussy Riot' were jailed for two years following their anti-Vladimir Putin protest in Moscow Cathedral. I can see why they caused a stir, but two years in jail?! This disproportionate sentence just shows the zero tolerance Putin and his Kremlin has for different opinions, and how he is happy to let Russia's reputation suffer for what was a personal criticism on his own repressive anti-LGBT policies. What an extreme way to deal with it, and what a way to fuel the fire of those he is trying to silence.

In another recent story from Russia, a ban was upheld for Pride celebrations in Moscow for 100 years. Firstly, 100 years?! This length would be laughable if it wasn't so infuriating. Pride is not about saying we are better than anyone. We are only saying we are equal and we are normal, just like everyone else. Generations of Russian LGBT people will grow up feeling scared, ashamed and discriminated against. To shroud sexual orientation with such shame will only breed a generation of more troubled people for Russia's increasingly questionable future.

Even the sporting world isn't free from this discrimination, as earlier this month The Russian government banned gay activists from creating a Pride House - a welcoming place for all athletes, spectators and friends - at the 2014 Winter Olympics in Sochi.  
 
In yet another news story, pop icon Madonna is currently being sued by a group of activists claiming she broke the law by promoting homosexuality at a recent concert in St Petersburg. You can maybe understand why there was a bit of an uproar as she stomped on an Orthodox cross, and that is likely to rile up some religious types. But this is Madonna; she has always been pulling stunts like this, she has always gained notoriety for her controversial use of religious paraphernalia in her performances. However, what I am most shocked about in this lawsuit is the complaint against Madonna for asking the audience to raise their pink armbands in the air to show support for the lesbian and gay people in the crowd. Is this something the law even needs to be involved with? Maybe a more pertinent question is, should this 'offence' cost Madonna the $10 million she is being sued for?

The answer is quite frankly no. You cannot promote homosexuality as a choice. Madonna will not have 'converted' the impressionable youth in her audience to suddenly be gay. If they were gay, they were always going to be gay.

I cannot believe that a government, who is in charge of a whole country, can truly believe that 'gay-ness' can be 'spread' or 'promoted' like it's a lifestyle choice. Their lack of knowledge not only angers me, but worries me. How do these people get into power?

It's times like this I realise how much I take for granted.

I go to Manchester Pride every year, and bar the odd religious protester or thuggish youth, we never get much grief. I feel relatively safe to go out with my friends and we feel assured and confident not to hide who we are.

And this year will be no different. This weekend I will be proudly walking through the streets of Manchester. After this wave of gay hate coming out of Russia, instead of my usual surprising tolerance for the religious groups at the side of the parade, banners in hand and hate in their hearts, I think this year it will be hard for my to hide my frustration. If everyone is entitled to their opinion, even in a place where their 'opposition' chooses to celebrate, like a Pride festival, why can't Pussy Riot do their alternative 'prayer' protest in the cathedral without facing imprisonment?

Back to the people though; my heart goes out to those who are living in fear every day. Every day it seems as if there is another story from Russia on this topic, and the momentum of anti-gay prejudice only seems to be growing. However, as their hate grows, so does our pride, and I feel that the harder Putin tries to silence our Russian LGBT brothers and sisters, the louder they will shout. And we, as LGBT people, no, as human beings, should help them raise the decibels.

More images

Video

DIVA Linked Stories

Comments