Thank you for letting us know. We will review this comment.

COOKIES & PRIVACY POLICY

Gay marriage is "pointless", claims Glasgow's Archbishop

A top Scottish Catholic Leader has attacked proposals of same sex marriage saying it would be “pointless” and “foolish”.

Peter Lloyd

Fri, 09 Sep 2011 15:18:26 GMT | Updated 1 years today

Mario Conti, the Archbishop of Glasgow, wrote in a letter to The Herald that gay marriage would be pointless, as it would not create a "natural family".

He also criticized the Scottish Government's 14-week consultation over whether to allow religious ceremonies for civil partnerships and the introduction of same sex marriage.

A Scottish Social Attitudes Survey found sixty-one per cent of the Scottish public support allowing gay couples to wed. The Archbishop said supporters of this poll are "foolish".

He wrote: "In a proposed consultation regarding the redefinition of civil partnerships, we are talking not of human rights or of civil liberties, nor of legal or fiscal equalities, but of redefining a particular relationship to give it a meaning it doesn't possess.

"We would use a word which carries huge significance, and render it meaningless in respect of one of its essential attributes, its capacity to create a natural family - I mean of course marriage.

"It hints also at a hubristic mentality on the part of those in power, who imagine that today they can call something what it was not yesterday, and tomorrow tell us that black is white."

Scotland, along with the rest of the UK, allows civil partnerships between same sex couples.  However, this does not mean full marriage equality and campaigners are hoping that Archbishop Conti's letter will not sway minister's opinions.

More images

Video

DIVA Linked Stories

Comments

  • Kym Cochrane - Sat, 10 Sep 2011 19:12:23 GMT -

    Report Abuse

    Archbishops are pointless says gay couple

  • Pagan Hare - Sat, 10 Sep 2011 20:23:02 GMT -

    Report Abuse

    Marriage is about LOVE not children not family....Those are the other things that CAN go along with a marriage!! In my opinion marriage is pointless if it's ONLY about family!!! And what is a 'natural' family anyway? there are plenty of hetro families that are full of un-natural acts such as violence!! What is most important is the child is loved and we have proved plenty of times that we can give that. We don't need to be married to someone of the opposite sex to prove that do we!!! Archibishop...YOU are pointless!!!

  • Kate Lorimer - Mon, 12 Sep 2011 09:35:23 GMT -

    Report Abuse

    My feeling having grown up in a town that could have been called Divorce-Town is that same-sex families (whether children are adopted or otherwise) would be a far more likely to succeed union...

  • Anwen Grant - Mon, 12 Sep 2011 09:58:43 GMT -

    Report Abuse

    Not to mention the fact that (assuming by 'natural family' he means something about the fact that straight couples can supposedly make babies just by having sex) LOTS of straight couples can't, or don't want to, have children. Are straight couples who adopt, use fertility treatments, have to give up on fertility treatment because it makes them ill, can't afford fertility treatments, or just don't actually want to be parents somehow not 'properly' married? Are their marriages pointless?

  • Riley House - Mon, 12 Sep 2011 17:39:29 GMT -

    Report Abuse

    So since it is "pointless" because gay couples can not naturally concieve does that mean that straight couples who are sterile or cannot concieve for one reason or another should not be permitted to marry or forced into divorce or a civil union?? Double standards are used all to often by governments.

  • Courtney Hendry - Fri, 07 Oct 2011 02:24:18 GMT -

    Report Abuse

    He just clearly doesn't understand what true love is. I'm telling you'se that's what it'll be. Marriage is about love. It doesn't mean "oh we're married, now we HAVE to have children". Nonsense. We can do what we want, and will do what we want and won't let people like you (Archbishop) hold us back. So carry on saying what you are saying, because it will get you absolutely nowhere I can assure you, time has moved on, you are stuck in the ice age. When the Scottish Youth Parliament made a petition to send the proposal of gay marriage to the Scottish Parliament, I voted on it and many other people do, so I really want this law to be passed. xx